2019 Silver Oak Napa Valley 1.5L estate spotlight
Silver Oak's own film on the American oak that shapes this Cabernet.


The market on this bottle
Wine-Searcher tracks this 2019 Silver Oak Cellars Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley across the open market. Their published U.S. low is $140.03 and the average is $178.34. Our slash is $285.00.
Napa Valley Cabernet magnum
1.5L Magnum 2019 Silver Oak Cellars Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley, USA
Nate Weis called the magnum the sweet size, so why would you open anything smaller than this Decanter 96?
Picture the steakhouse table where this name already sits, and picture the larger bottle in the middle of it. This is the 2019 Napa Cabernet, held five years in American oak, scored 96 by Decanter and 95 by James Suckling. Two or more are $257 a magnum. One is $285. If the wine is already proved, the only decision left is whether you take it home.
They shook hands on one wine, and they never added a second

In 1972 Ray Duncan and Justin Meyer shook hands on a bet most of California was not making. One wine. Cabernet Sauvignon, and American oak only. Meyer had learned the craft with the Christian Brothers. Duncan had been walked into the vineyards by his friend Jack Novak. The valleys did not yet have names a label could legally use, so those first bottles said North Coast, and when the 1972 finally reached a judging table, in 1977, it took gold at the California State Fair.
The label in front of you is black, which means Napa. A silver label would mean Alexander Valley. Nate Weis, the third winemaker after Meyer and Daniel Baron, kept the cellar from 2014 through 2025, the whole life of this 2019 before anyone was allowed to open it. He called a magnum the sweet size, and the house note carries the vintage through 2047. The scores are next. Read them before you decide which size you actually want.
The bet
One Cabernet, and a handshake that still holds.
The oak
American barrels, from a cooperage the family owns.
The proof
Decanter 96, and James Suckling at 95.
The bottle
A magnum, because the smaller one moves too fast.
The proof is already in the glass

Decanter sat with this 2019 and scored it 96, a compact glass of Bing cherry, black raspberry, tobacco, currant leaf, cedarwood, and dried sage. James Suckling came in at 95 and found it elegant, supple, and silky, with blueberries, dark chocolate, black fruit, mint, and cocoa.
The photograph is a pour into the house glasses. The scores belong to this vintage. That is the proof. What follows is how the wine got there, and what it asks you to do with it.
The cork says Life is a Cabernet

Pull the cork and the house has already written the thesis for you. Life is a Cabernet. The 2019 Napa is the paragraph under it: black cherry first, with a floral top, then huckleberry and dry flowers, a little sweet nutmeg from the oak, silky tannins, and a finish that refuses to hurry. Decanter's Bing cherry and dried sage are in that same sip.
Leave it alone and the winery says it keeps getting better through 2047. The nutmeg in the finish has an address, though. The barrels are next.
Bing cherry, black raspberry, tobacco, and a floral top.
Black cherry, huckleberry, blueberries, and dark chocolate.
Silky tannins, nutmeg, dried sage, and a long finish.
He tasted the French oak, and he walked the other way
The Napa Cabernet rests in American oak before anyone is allowed to open it.

Most of Napa, in those first years, was buying French oak. Meyer tasted the grippier tannin it laid on Cabernet and went the other direction: American oak, for the silk, the vanilla, and a finish that stays. More than fifty years later the house still has not blinked, and it stopped borrowing the barrels. Since 2015 Silver Oak has owned The Oak Cooperage in Missouri, the first North American winery to own the shop where its American oak is made.
What comes out of those barrels is Cabernet Sauvignon first, then Merlot, Cabernet Franc, Petit Verdot, and Malbec, and it sits five years before release. Daniel Baron, the winemaker between Meyer and Weis, had interned at Chateau Petrus. Weis held this vintage. You are not buying a one-year idea. You are buying the choice they refused to drop. The building they make it in is the one you drive up to.
Drive up, and the sign still says the same two words
David and Tim Duncan, Ray's sons, run the house now.



The first bottles went out at $6, in a time when most wine cost $3 or less, and people paid it. By 1990 Release Day had a line, and the line people still talk about is the one for magnums. After the 2006 fire the sons rebuilt Oakville, and that building became the first large-scale production winery to earn LEED Platinum. Alexander Valley later earned Platinum too, and in 2020 it earned Living Building certification. They have pointed the house at net zero by 2050.
Robb Report, writing in 2022, kept noticing the same table. The Cabernet in a serious restaurant was often Silver Oak, and often a magnum. VinePair said it in one breath: think of this name and you think of an American steakhouse. The huge bottle in the photograph is an older one, the 20th anniversary Napa from 1972 to 1992, so you can see the black label and the size they have always loved. The magnum you can take home is the 2019. Which is why the plate has always been steak.
Set the table the way the restaurants already do
Black cherry and tobacco want a peppercorn steak, and that long finish wants something salty to land on.
Crack the pepper over the steak, let the cream sauce catch the cedar and the black cherry, and put a basket of fries where the finish can land. This is the steakhouse Cabernet. Give it the plate it already knows, then give the magnum a short decant and pour.
Decant it briefly. Pour it while the steak is still hot. Two or more magnums are $257 each.
Steak au poivre
Peppercorn-crusted steaks with a pan sauce of brandy, stock, and cream.
Why it works: Cracked pepper and cream meet tobacco, cedarwood, and black cherry without fighting the silky tannins.
View Recipe for Steak au poivre (opens in a new tab)
French fries
Russet potatoes boiled with a little vinegar, then fried until thin and crisp.
Why it works: Salt and crisp potato give the long finish something plain to land on.
View Recipe for French fries (opens in a new tab)Add the magnums, and pour the first one
Decanter has already scored this 2019 a 96. Two or more are $257 a magnum. One is $285.
Add six now for $1,542, or take twelve for $3,084 and we ship them free in the lower 48. Pour the first one with the steak tonight. Let the others wait until 2047. The next move is yours.